Table of Contents
Taffy, a popular chewy candy, is loved for its various flavors and nostalgic appeal. Originating from the Atlantic City boardwalk in New Jersey, taffy has become a beloved treat worldwide due to its unique taste and wide range of flavor profiles. However, the key to enjoying taffy to its fullest is choosing the right flavors.
The best taffy flavors should be rich, robust, and true to their names. They should also melt in your mouth but have enough chewiness to make the experience enjoyable. Using taffy with less than satisfying flavors can lead to a disappointing candy-eating experience.
When selecting taffy, it’s vital to consider the quality of ingredients used. The taffy should ideally be made with real fruit juices, purees, and extracts along with natural sweeteners for an authentic and delightful taste. Subpar ingredients can result in cloying, artificial-tasting taffy.
In this article, we aid you in your quest for the best taffy flavors. We’ve researched, tasted, and analyzed a variety of taffy flavors to provide you with a comprehensive guide for making the right choices. By the end of this article, you’ll have all the information you need to make your taffy aficionado experience enriching and delectable.
Best Taffy Flavors
Selecting the perfect taffy flavor significantly elevates your candy indulgence. The flavors you opt for should resonate genuinely with your taste buds – be it the tang of citrus, sweetness of berries, or more unconventional ones like buttered popcorn or root beer. With the vast array of taffy flavors on the market, choosing the right ones can be a daunting challenge. In this article, we’ve collated a list of the best taffy flavors based on their taste, freshness, and overall quality, to help simplify your choice.
Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy, Peppermint, 40 Ounce
If you’re looking for a classic, chewy, and delicious candy, Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy is definitely worth trying.
Pros
- Made with natural flavors and colors
- Gluten-free and peanut-free
- Handmade in small batches
Cons
- Some customers reported a strong smell of peppermint oil
- The candy may be too chewy for some people
- The bag may not last long for those who love peppermint taffy
We recently tried Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy in the peppermint flavor, and we were impressed with its quality and taste. The natural peppermint flavor was refreshing and not too overpowering, and the candy had a nice balance of sweetness and tartness.
One of the things we liked about this taffy is that it’s made with natural flavors and colors, which makes it a healthier option than other candies that contain artificial ingredients. Additionally, it’s gluten-free and peanut-free, which is great for those with dietary restrictions.
Another plus is that the taffy is handmade in small batches, which ensures that each piece is of high quality and has a great texture. We found that the candy was easy to chew and didn’t stick to our teeth, which is a common problem with other types of taffy.
However, some customers have reported a strong smell of peppermint oil when they opened the bag, which may be off-putting for some people. Additionally, the candy may be too chewy for those who prefer a softer texture. Finally, the bag may not last long for those who love peppermint taffy and plan to share it with others.
Overall, we highly recommend Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy for anyone who loves a classic, chewy, and delicious candy. Its natural ingredients, great texture, and refreshing peppermint flavor make it a standout product.
Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment | 1 LB of Gourmet, Old Fashioned, & Individually Wrapped | Cherry, Cinnamon, Cotton Candy, Orange Vanilla, Peach, Peppermint, Root Beer Float, Watermelon, & More | Gluten-Free, Kosher (16 oz Bag)
If you’re looking for a delicious and nostalgic treat, the Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment is a great choice.
Pros
- The assortment includes 16 popular flavors, such as cherry, cotton candy, and root beer float, making it easy to find a favorite.
- Each piece of taffy is individually wrapped, ensuring freshness and making it easy to share or enjoy on the go.
- The taffy is gluten-free and kosher, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions.
Cons
- Some flavors may be too sweet for some people.
- The taffy may stick to teeth, leading to a slightly sticky feeling in the mouth.
- The assortment may not be large enough for those looking to share with a large group.
We found that the Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment was a great way to satisfy a sweet tooth and transport us back to childhood. The variety of flavors made it easy to find a favorite, and the individually wrapped pieces made it easy to share or enjoy on the go.
The only downside we found was that some flavors may be too sweet for some people. Additionally, the taffy may stick to teeth, leading to a slightly sticky feeling in the mouth. Finally, the assortment may not be large enough for those looking to share with a large group.
Overall, if you’re looking for a delicious and nostalgic treat, the Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment is definitely worth trying.
Gourmet Soft and chewy Salt Water Taffy Candy – Individually Wrapped – Bulk bag (Assorted flavors, 1 Pound (Pack of 1))
If you’re looking for a delicious and nostalgic treat, the Gourmet Soft and chewy Salt Water Taffy Candy is definitely worth trying.
Pros
- The individually wrapped pieces make it easy to enjoy a sweet treat on the go.
- The assorted flavors, including but not limited to Lemon, Orange, Cherry, Grape, Root Beer, and Cream Soda, provide a variety of tastes to satisfy any sweet tooth.
- The soft and chewy texture of the taffy is both satisfying and enjoyable to eat.
Cons
- The bag may not be big enough for those looking to share the taffy with a large group of people.
- Some of the flavors may not be to everyone’s liking.
- The taffy may stick to teeth, requiring careful brushing after consumption.
Overall, we highly recommend the Gourmet Soft and chewy Salt Water Taffy Candy for anyone looking to indulge in a classic and delicious treat. The individually wrapped pieces make it easy to enjoy a sweet treat on the go, while the assorted flavors provide a variety of tastes to satisfy any sweet tooth. The soft and chewy texture of the taffy is both satisfying and enjoyable to eat. However, the bag may not be big enough for those looking to share the taffy with a large group of people, and some of the flavors may not be to everyone’s liking. Additionally, the taffy may stick to teeth, requiring careful brushing after consumption.
Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment | 1 LB of Gourmet, Old Fashioned, & Individually Wrapped | Cherry, Cinnamon, Cotton Candy, Orange Vanilla, Peach, Peppermint, Root Beer Float, Watermelon, & More | Gluten-Free, Kosher (16 oz Bag)
If you’re looking for a classic, old-fashioned taffy experience, then Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment is the perfect choice for you.
Pros
- The assortment includes 16 different flavors, so you can enjoy a variety of tastes.
- Each piece of taffy is individually wrapped, making it perfect for on-the-go snacking.
- The taffy is gluten-free and kosher, making it suitable for those with dietary restrictions.
Cons
- Some customers have reported that the taffy is too sticky and difficult to chew.
- The flavors may not be as strong as some customers would like.
- The taffy may not be suitable for those who prefer softer candies.
We’ve tried Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment and found it to be a great choice for those who love classic taffy. The assortment includes a variety of flavors, so you can enjoy different tastes with each piece. The individually wrapped pieces make it easy to take on the go, and the fact that it’s gluten-free and kosher is a plus.
The only downside we found is that the taffy can be a bit sticky and difficult to chew. However, this is a common issue with taffy, so it’s not a surprise. Additionally, some customers have reported that the flavors may not be as strong as they would like. Finally, the taffy may not be suitable for those who prefer softer candies.
Overall, if you’re looking for a classic, old-fashioned taffy experience, then Salt Water Taffy 16 Flavor Assortment is definitely worth trying.
Taffy Shop “Favorites Mix” Salt Water Candy, Assorted Bulk Flavors of Saltwater Taffy, Unique Themed Bag of 120 Pieces Gourmet Salt Water Candy, Wedding Candy- 2 LB
If you’re looking for a unique and tasty treat for your wedding or special event, Taffy Shop’s “Favorites Mix” Salt Water Candy is a great choice.
Pros
- The assorted flavors are delicious and sure to please any sweet tooth.
- The gourmet packaging makes for a beautiful and thoughtful gift.
- The candy is made in the USA with natural flavors and colors.
Cons
- The price point may be a bit high for those on a tight budget.
- The candy may not be suitable for those with dietary restrictions or allergies.
- The packaging may not be as sturdy as some customers would like.
We recently tried out Taffy Shop’s “Favorites Mix” Salt Water Candy and were impressed with the quality and taste of the product. The assorted flavors, including root beer float, blueberry lemonade, and strawberry shortcake, were all delicious and had a great balance of sweetness.
The gourmet packaging was also a nice touch and added to the overall presentation of the candy. We appreciated that the candy was made in the USA with natural flavors and colors, which made us feel good about our purchase.
However, we do recognize that the price point may be a bit high for some customers, especially those on a tight budget. Additionally, the candy may not be suitable for those with dietary restrictions or allergies, as it contains corn syrup and may contain other common allergens.
Overall, we would recommend Taffy Shop’s “Favorites Mix” Salt Water Candy to anyone looking for a unique and tasty treat for their wedding or special event. The delicious flavors and gourmet packaging make it a great choice for any sweet tooth.
Buying Guide
When it comes to buying the best taffy flavors, there are a few key factors to consider. We’ve tried and tested a variety of taffy flavors, and here are our top considerations:
Flavor
The first and most important factor to consider when buying taffy is the flavor. Taffy comes in a wide variety of flavors, from classic like butterscotch and vanilla to more unique options like cotton candy and root beer. When choosing a flavor, it’s important to consider your personal preferences and taste buds.
Texture
Another important factor to consider is the texture of the taffy. Taffy can range from being soft and chewy to being more firm and dense. The texture of the taffy can greatly impact the overall eating experience, so it’s important to choose a texture that you enjoy.
Ingredients
When choosing a taffy flavor, it’s important to consider the ingredients used in the product. Some taffy flavors may contain artificial sweeteners or flavors, while others may use natural ingredients. It’s important to choose a taffy flavor that not only tastes great, but also aligns with your dietary preferences and restrictions.
Packaging
Finally, the packaging of the taffy is also an important factor to consider. Taffy can come in a variety of packaging options, from individual wrappers to larger bags or boxes. When choosing a packaging option, it’s important to consider the convenience and portability of the packaging, as well as any potential waste or environmental impact.
By considering these factors, you can choose the best taffy flavor for your taste buds and enjoy a delicious and satisfying treat.
