Table of Contents
Butcher block countertops are a timeless choice for any kitchen, known for their durability and classic design. However, to ensure these countertops stand the test of time, it’s crucial to find the right finish. The best finish for butcher block countertops should be food-safe, durable, and resistant to both moisture and heat. Incorrectly sealed or maintained butcher block countertops can lead to water damage, stain, and unsightly wear.
When choosing a finish for your butcher block countertops, it’s important to read the label and look at the composition. The finish should ideally be a blend of natural oils and waxes, and other protective agents that can stand up to the daily wear and tear of a busy kitchen. Choosing the right finish will provide long-lasting protection, making your countertops last for years.
In this article, we will guide you through the process of selecting the best finish for your butcher block countertops. Drawing from our expertise and rigorous testing of various finishes, we will recommend those that offer the best protection and enhance the natural beauty of your butcher block. By the end of this article, you’ll be equipped with all the information you need to keep your butcher block countertops looking brand new.
Best Finish For Butcher Block Countertops
Identifying the right finish for your butcher block countertops is essential for their functionality and longevity. The finish should effectively seal and protect the wood while allowing its unique beauty to shine through. In a marketplace filled with numerous options, deciding on the best one can be quite daunting. In this article, we have compiled a list of the best finishes for butcher block countertops, based on our firsthand experience and extensive testing, to help guide you in making an informed decision.
Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil – 12oz Food Grade Conditioner for Wood Cutting Board, Countertop & Butcher Block, Lubricant for Knife or Meat Grinder – Safe USP Finish on Marble, Soapstone
If you’re looking for a wood conditioner that’s safe to use on your cutting board, butcher block, or countertop, Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil is a great option.
Pros
- Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil is food safe and meets USP standards, so you can use it on surfaces that come into contact with food.
- It’s easy to apply and only requires a few drops to condition a large cutting board.
- Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil helps prevent cracking and drying, which can extend the life of your wood surfaces.
Cons
- Some users have reported that the oil can leave a slight residue on the surface, which can be difficult to clean off.
- Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil may not be suitable for all types of wood, so it’s important to test it on a small area first.
- The bottle only contains 12 ounces of oil, which may not be enough to condition larger surfaces.
We’ve used Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil on our wooden cutting board and have been happy with the results. The oil is easy to apply and has helped prevent the board from drying out or cracking. We’ve also used it on our butcher block and have noticed a difference in how easily the knife glides across the surface.
One thing to keep in mind is that the oil can leave a slight residue on the surface, which can be difficult to clean off. However, we’ve found that this is only an issue if too much oil is used. Overall, we would recommend Thirteen Chefs Mineral Oil to anyone looking for a safe and effective way to condition their wood surfaces.
Rust-Oleum Corporation Watco 241758 Butcher Block Oil & Finish, Clear
If you’re looking for a high-quality butcher block oil and finish, the Rust-Oleum Corporation Watco 241758 Butcher Block Oil & Finish, Clear is a great option to consider.
Pros
- This finish is made in the USA with imported and domestic ingredients.
- It provides superior food safety by meeting NSF H1 requirements.
- The finish is easy to apply and leaves a beautiful, natural-looking finish.
Cons
- The finish has a strong odor that can be difficult to work with.
- It may require multiple coats for optimal protection.
- The finish may not be suitable for all types of wood.
We’ve used the Rust-Oleum Corporation Watco 241758 Butcher Block Oil & Finish, Clear to finish our butcher block countertops, and we’re impressed with the results. The finish is easy to apply and leaves a beautiful, natural-looking finish that enhances the beauty of the wood. We also appreciate that the finish is made in the USA and meets NSF H1 requirements for food safety.
One of the downsides of this finish is the strong odor it emits during application. It’s important to work in a well-ventilated area and wear a mask to avoid inhaling the fumes. Additionally, the finish may require multiple coats for optimal protection, which can be time-consuming.
Overall, if you’re looking for a high-quality butcher block oil and finish that provides superior food safety and enhances the beauty of your wood, the Rust-Oleum Corporation Watco 241758 Butcher Block Oil & Finish, Clear is definitely worth considering.
Watco 359024 Butcher Block Oil Plus Stain, 16 Ounce, Hazelnut
If you’re looking for a natural oil finish for your butcher block, the Watco 359024 Butcher Block Oil Plus Stain is a great option.
Pros
- Provides a natural look and feel
- Easy to apply
- Dries to a beautiful, long-lasting finish
Cons
- Requires a few coats for a durable finish
- May leave a slightly oily residue
- Scent may be overpowering for some
This product is perfect for those who want to maintain the natural look and feel of their butcher block. The Watco 359024 Butcher Block Oil Plus Stain is easy to apply and dries to a beautiful, long-lasting finish. However, it does require a few coats for a durable finish, and it may leave a slightly oily residue. Additionally, the scent may be overpowering for some.
The Watco 359024 Butcher Block Oil Plus Stain is made in the USA and is a water-based, food-safe finish. It’s perfect for use on butcher blocks, cutting boards, countertops, and other wood surfaces. This product is also great for maintaining and restoring your wood surfaces to their original beauty.
Overall, if you’re looking for a natural oil finish for your butcher block, the Watco 359024 Butcher Block Oil Plus Stain is a great option. It provides a beautiful finish and is easy to apply.
WALRUS OIL – Cutting Board Oil and Wood Butcher Block Oil, 32 oz Jug, Food-Safe
If you’re looking for a natural and safe cutting board oil, then the WALRUS OIL is a great choice.
Pros
- The oil is 100% food-safe and made in the USA.
- It is easy to apply and leaves a beautiful finish on the wood.
- The oil penetrates deeply into the wood, protecting it from drying and cracking.
Cons
- The oil has a slight odor that may linger for a few days.
- It may take several applications to achieve the desired level of protection.
- The oil may not be suitable for all types of wood.
We’ve been using the WALRUS OIL for a few weeks now, and we’re happy with the results. The oil is easy to apply, and it leaves a beautiful finish on the wood. We’ve noticed that the oil has penetrated deeply into the wood, protecting it from drying and cracking.
One of the things we like about this oil is that it is 100% food-safe and made in the USA. We feel confident using it on our cutting board and butcher block. The oil is also safe for use on marble, granite, and other surfaces.
Another benefit of this oil is that it is easy to apply. We simply applied the oil evenly to the surface of the wood, and then we let it sit for a few hours before wiping off any excess. We repeated this process several times to achieve the desired level of protection.
While the oil has a slight odor, we didn’t find it to be overwhelming. The odor did dissipate after a few days. However, we did notice that it took several applications of the oil to achieve the desired level of protection.
Overall, we would recommend the WALRUS OIL to anyone looking for a natural and safe cutting board oil. It provides excellent protection for your wood surfaces, and it leaves a beautiful finish that you’ll love.
Heritage Products Cutting Board Oil & Wax Applicator
If you’re looking for a high-quality wood conditioner, the Heritage Products Cutting Board Oil & Wax Applicator is a great choice.
Pros
- The sturdy handle and wooden cap make it easy to apply the oil or wax evenly and without spills.
- The food-safe mineral oil conditioner and beeswax renews and protects your wood, restoring it to its natural beauty.
- It’s made in the USA, and the product and process are both safe for you and your family.
Cons
- It’s a bit pricey compared to other wood conditioners on the market.
- The wood conditioner needs to be applied frequently, depending on the usage and exposure to moisture and heat.
- The conditioner may leave a residue if not applied evenly or if too much is used.
We’ve used the Heritage Products Cutting Board Oil & Wax Applicator to condition our wooden cutting board, and we’re impressed with the results. The sturdy handle and wooden cap make it easy to apply the oil evenly without any spills. The food-safe mineral oil conditioner and beeswax renewed and protected our wood, restoring it to its natural beauty.
One of the best things about this product is that it’s made in the USA, and the product and process are both safe for you and your family. We appreciate that Heritage Products is committed to providing high-quality, safe products for their customers.
However, the Heritage Products Cutting Board Oil & Wax Applicator is a bit pricey compared to other wood conditioners on the market. Additionally, the wood conditioner needs to be applied frequently, depending on the usage and exposure to moisture and heat. If too much conditioner is used or it’s not applied evenly, a residue may be left behind.
Overall, if you’re looking for a high-quality wood conditioner that will restore your wood to its natural beauty, the Heritage Products Cutting Board Oil & Wax Applicator is a great choice. Just be prepared to spend a bit more money and apply the conditioner frequently to keep your wood looking its best.
Buying Guide
When it comes to choosing the best finish for butcher block countertops, there are several factors to consider. We have used and tested various finishes, and here are the key features to look for:
Type of Finish
The type of finish is an essential factor to consider when choosing a product for your butcher block countertops. There are two main types of finishes: oil-based and water-based. Oil-based finishes are more durable and provide better protection against stains and scratches. However, they require more maintenance and may not be suitable for people with allergies to certain oils. On the other hand, water-based finishes are easier to maintain and are suitable for people with allergies. They also provide good protection against stains and scratches but may not be as durable as oil-based finishes.
Ingredients
When choosing a finish for your butcher block countertops, it is essential to consider the ingredients. Some finishes may contain harmful chemicals that can be harmful to your health or the environment. Look for finishes that are made from natural ingredients and are free from harmful chemicals.
Application
The application method is another critical factor to consider when choosing a finish for your butcher block countertops. Some finishes require multiple coats, while others only require one. Additionally, some finishes require a long drying time, while others can be used immediately after application.
Price
Price is always a consideration when choosing a finish for your butcher block countertops. While some finishes may be more expensive, they may provide better protection and last longer. On the other hand, cheaper finishes may not provide the same level of protection and may need to be reapplied more frequently.
In summary, when choosing the best finish for your butcher block countertops, consider the type of finish, ingredients, application method, and price. By taking these factors into account, you can choose a finish that will provide the best protection and last for years to come.
